I'm going to pick #2. I don't know which one you picked, but that's the one i would pick for you. I think it complements your coloring and the shape of your face the best. But of course, you look great in all 4 of them! I recently went through the same thing, picking out new frames, and after an eternity I wound up with almost the same ones, but only a pink tint to them. Creature of habit, I guess!